Collaboration is the only way to fix “generational” employment challenges, say LSIP organisations.
A group of employers and education providers in the Liverpool City Region has welcomed the Milburn Report but says the government must work with them to fix the problem of youth unemployment.
The Local Skills Improvement Plan (LSIP) offers employers a direct line of communication with schools, colleges and education policymakers to ensure that training courses meet the real needs of businesses, ultimately improving career opportunities for young people.
The group, which includes some of the City Region’s largest employers and education providers, and is convened by Liverpool Chamber, says the Milburn Report is an opportunity for the government to work with key stakeholders from all backgrounds to reduce the number of young NEETs and finally tackle the “generational” problem of youth employability.
Among the recommendations of the MIlburn Report is raising the threshold at which employers make National Insurance Contributions for non-apprentice workers aged 21-24 to encourage more businesses to hire young people. It also proposes a ‘legal guarantee’ of a job, training or employment for young people, with benefits lost for those who fail to engage.
Delivering the report, its author Alan Milburn spoke about “changing the deal with businesses”, focussing as much on the demand side as supply and making it less risky for employers to create jobs. The report also advocates for less new regulation that makes it difficult to hire young people, the creation of a ‘Youth Allowance’ to replace some existing benefits, and greater control for devolved locations such as the Liverpool City Region.
Paul Cherpeau, chief executive of Liverpool Chamber, said:
“Over the past two years, we have seen meaningful dialogue and outcomes from the work of the LSIP and it is a live, working example of the power of communication and collaboration. Employers and educators mutually willing to give their time, insight and trust to one another, with a shared purpose of helping more young people get the skills and jobs they need.
“The resounding message is that the government needs to help lower the cost burden of hiring for employers, improve access to any support that’s available, and enhance the work readiness of young people to improve outcomes for them and for their new employers.
“The essence of the LSIP partnership has to be mirrored if we are to find sustainable solutions to youth employability. While some of the measures in the Milburn Report require much further scrutiny, its publication should be the catalyst for a national conversation and a chance to amplify the impact of partnership working at a much larger scale.”
Liam Hanlon, director at The Forshaw Group, said:
“If the Government genuinely wants to tackle youth unemployment and improve social mobility, it must move beyond funding the supply of training and skills and start investing in the demand for young people within the labour market.
“That means meaningful, accessible, and sustained financial incentives for businesses that recruit, train, and retain young people. It means reducing the financial risks of taking on inexperienced employees and recognising the contribution employers make to developing the next generation of the workforce.
“Without businesses willing and able to employ young people, there will be no meaningful employment opportunities, no sustainable career pathways and ultimately no improvement in social mobility. The question that needs to be answered is simple: where is the equivalent commitment to supporting the businesses expected to deliver these employment opportunities?
“Until Government policy recognises that employers, and particularly SMEs, must be at the centre of the solution rather than simply treated as the final destination for publicly funded training, I fear we will continue to see the same disappointing outcomes, regardless of how much money is invested elsewhere in the system.”
Lisa Johnson, director at Square One Training, said:
“We welcome many of the ideas put forward so far. The proposed reduction in employer National Insurance for 21- to 24-year-olds would be a positive step. With wages and training costs rising, it could give businesses more room to take on and develop young people.
“Our concern is that if more young people come into entry-level jobs and those already in those roles have few opportunities to progress, we could end up with more people competing for the same jobs. If the proposal goes ahead, I’d like to see the government give training and development a clear place alongside measures to encourage hiring.
“For us, that means putting more emphasis on creating job opportunities through progression. If we give existing staff the chance to build their skills and take on more responsibility, that can open up entry-level roles for others who are just starting out.”